Semi-gloss, Eggshell, Flat? Your Guide On Choosing The Right Paint Sheen

Picking the perfect paint color is tough enough — now I have to decide on a sheen level? This is a common occurrence for homeowners, property managers, architects, and DIYers.

Choosing an interior paint color is only half the decision. Selecting the right paint sheen is what determines how your walls will actually look and perform—especially in Seattle homes, where changing light, higher humidity, and daily wear can quickly expose the wrong choice. 

As experienced interior painters in Seattle, we help homeowners choose paint finishes that don’t just look great on day one, but continue to perform through dark winters, bright summer light, and everyday living. This guide breaks down each paint sheen, where it works best, and how to choose the right one for your Seattle home. 

What is Paint Sheen?

Let's start with the basics and define what exactly paint sheen is. To put it simply, paint sheen is the level of gloss or shine in the paint finish. The sheen level tells you how much light the paint reflects. Paints with higher sheens are shinier, and paints with lower sheens reflect less light. Higher-sheen paints have more enamel in them, which makes them shinier, more durable, and easier to clean. Lower-sheen paints are easier to look at because they have little to no glare. Here's a chart of the most popular sheen levels by most manufacturers.

In the Seattle area, paint sheen matters more because: 

• Natural light changes dramatically by season 

• Many homes have older drywall or textured walls 

• Moisture levels are higher year-round 

  
  

The wrong sheen can highlight imperfections, show scuffs quickly, or fail in high-use areas. The right sheen improves durability, appearance, and long-term value. 

What Is Paint Sheen (and Why It Matters in Seattle Homes) 

Paint sheen refers to how much light reflects off a painted surface. The higher the sheen, the more shine, and generally, the more durable and washable the paint becomes. 

In the Seattle area, paint sheen matters more because: 

• Natural light changes dramatically by season 

• Many homes have older drywall or textured walls 

• Moisture levels are higher year-round 

  
  

The wrong sheen can highlight imperfections, show scuffs quickly, or fail in high-use areas. The right sheen improves durability, appearance, and long-term value. 

The Most Common Interior Paint Sheens Explained 

Flat (Matte) Paint 

Flat paint has little to no shine and absorbs light rather than reflecting it. 

Best for: 

• Ceilings 

• Guest rooms 

• Low-traffic areas 

Pros: 

• Excellent at hiding imperfections 

• Soft, modern appearance 

Cons: 

• Least durable 

• Difficult to clean 

Seattle homeowners often choose flat finishes for ceilings to reduce glare from artificial lighting. When applied correctly, flat paint delivers a clean, high-end look. Our interior painting services in Seattle include proper surface prep to ensure flat finishes look smooth and intentional. 

The Most Common Interior Paint Sheens Explained 

Eggshell Paint 

Eggshell is one of the most popular interior paint sheens and for good reason. 

Best for: 

• Living rooms 

• Dining rooms 

• Bedrooms 

Pros: 

• Subtle sheen with a warm appearance 

• More durable than flat 

• Easy to touch up 

Cons: 

• Not ideal for high-moisture spaces 

  
  

Eggshell performs especially well in Seattle homes with moderate natural light, offering a warm finish without highlighting wall flaws. 

Satin Paint 

Satin has a smooth, velvety finish with noticeable durability. 

Best for: 

• Hallways 

• Family rooms 

• Kids’ bedrooms 

Pros: 

• Washable and moisture-resistant 

• Holds up well in high-traffic areas 

Cons: 

• Shows surface flaws if walls aren’t properly prepared 

Many Seattle homes benefit from satin finishes, but only when walls are professionally sanded and patched beforehand. Poor prep is one of the most common causes of dissatisfaction with satin paint. 

Semi-Gloss Paint 

Semi-gloss is highly durable and reflective. 

Best for: 

• Trim and baseboards 

• Doors 

• Kitchens and bathrooms 

  
  

Pros: 

• Extremely easy to clean 

• Resistant to moisture and wear 

  
  

Cons: 

• Highlights imperfections 

• Requires expert prep and application 

  
  

Semi-gloss is ideal for moisture-prone spaces common in Seattle homes. It’s also the go-to finish for cabinets and trim. If you’re updating these areas, our cabinet painting and refinishing services in Seattle deliver a smooth, factory-quality finish without brush marks. 

High-Gloss Paint (Use Sparingly) 

High-gloss delivers a dramatic, mirror-like finish. 

Best for: 

• Accent trim 

• Modern design elements 

Pros: 

• Maximum durability 

• Striking visual impact 

Cons: 

• Shows every flaw 

• Not forgiving for DIY projects 

High-gloss finishes are best left to professionals with specialized tools and experience. 

Choosing the Right Paint Sheen Room by Room 

Living Rooms & Bedrooms 

Best sheen: Eggshell or satin 

Kitchens & Bathrooms 

Best sheen: Satin or semi-gloss 

Trim, Doors & Cabinets 

Best sheen: Semi-gloss or high-gloss 

Ceilings 

Best sheen: Flat 

Common Paint Sheen Mistakes Seattle Homeowners Make 

Choosing Shine Over Practicality 

Higher sheen isn’t always better. 

Skipping Proper Surface Preparation 

Sheen magnifies flaws, especially in older Seattle homes. 

Ignoring Natural and Artificial Lighting 

Sheen changes dramatically throughout the day. 

When to Call a Professional Interior Painter in Seattle 

If you’re unsure about: 

• Which sheen fits your lifestyle 

• How lighting will affect the finish 

• Whether your walls can handle higher-gloss paints 

A professional consultation can save you from costly repainting. Our Seattle interior painters help homeowners choose finishes that look great and last. 

Call to Action: Get Expert Help Choosing the Right Paint Sheen 

Not sure which paint sheen is right for your Seattle home? 

Request a free in-home estimate from Brotherton Painting and get expert guidance from trusted Seattle interior painting professionals. 

Paint Sheen FAQs 

What is the best paint sheen for Seattle homes? 

Eggshell and satin offer the best balance of durability and appearance. 

Is flat paint still a good option?

Yes, especially for ceilings and low-traffic rooms. 

What paint sheen is easiest to clean

Semi-gloss and satin finishes. 

Can I use one sheen throughout my home? 

You can, but performance improves when sheens vary by room.